rwp - Jude:1

rwp@Jude:1:2 @{Be multiplied} (\plthunthei\). First aorist passive optative of \plthun\ as in strkjv@1Peter:1:2; strkjv@2Peter:1:2|.

rwp@Jude:1:3 @{Beloved} (\agaptoi\). As in strkjv@3John:1:2|. {All diligence} (\psan spoudn\). As in strkjv@2Peter:1:5|. {Of our common salvation} (\peri ts koins hmn strias\). See this use of \koinos\ (common to all) in strkjv@Titus:1:4| with \pistis\, while in strkjv@2Peter:1:1| we have \isotimon pistin\, which see. {I was constrained} (\anagkn eschon\). "I had necessity" like strkjv@Luke:14:18; strkjv@Hebrews:7:27|. {To contend earnestly} (\epagnizesthai\). Late and rare (in Plutarch, inscriptions) compound, here only in N.T. A little additional (\epi\) striving to the already strong \agnizesthai\ (\agn\ contest). Cf. strkjv@1Timothy:6:12| \agnizou ton kalon agna\. {For the faith} (\ti--pistei\). Dative of advantage. Here not in the original sense of trust, but rather of the thing believed as in verse 20; strkjv@Galatians:1:23; strkjv@3:23; strkjv@Phillipians:1:27|. {Once for all delivered} (\hapax paradotheisi\). First aorist passive participle feminine dative singular of \paradidmi\, for which see strkjv@2Peter:2:21|. See also strkjv@2Thessalonians:2:15; strkjv@1Corinthians:11:2; strkjv@1Timothy:6:20|.

rwp@Jude:1:4 @{Are crept in} (\pareisedusan\). Second aorist passive indicative of \pareisdu\ (\-n\), late (Hippocrates, Plutarch, etc.) compound of \para\ (beside) and \eis\ (in) and \du\ to sink or plunge, so to slip in secretly as if by a side door, here only in N.T. {Set forth} (\progegrammenoi\). Perfect passive participle of \prograph\, to write of beforehand, for which verb see strkjv@Galatians:3:1; strkjv@Romans:15:4|. {Unto this condemnation} (\eis touto to krima\). See strkjv@2Peter:2:3| for \krima\ and \ekpalai\. \Palai\ here apparently alludes to verses 14,15| (Enoch). {Ungodly men} (\asebeis\). Keynote of the Epistle (Mayor), in 15| again as in strkjv@2Peter:2:5; strkjv@3:7|. {Turning} (\metatithentes\). Present active participle of \metatithmi\, to change, for which verb see strkjv@Galatians:1:6|. For the change of "grace" (\charita\) into "lasciviousness (\eis aselgeian\) see strkjv@1Peter:2:16; strkjv@4:3; strkjv@2Peter:2:19; strkjv@3:16|. {Our only Master and Lord} (\ton monon despotn kai kurion hmn\). For the force of the one article for one person see on ¯2Peter:1:1|. For \despotn\ of Christ see strkjv@2Peter:2:1|. {Denying} (\arnoumenoi\). strkjv@Songs:2Peter:2:1|. See also strkjv@Matthew:10:33; strkjv@1Timothy:5:8; strkjv@Titus:1:16; strkjv@1John:2:22|.

rwp@Jude:1:5 @{To put you in remembrance} (\hupomnsai\). See strkjv@2Peter:1:12| \hupomimnskein\ (present active infinitive there, first aorist active infinitive here). {Though ye know all things once for all} (\eidotas hapax panta\). Concessive perfect (sense of present) active participle as in strkjv@2Peter:1:12|, but without \kaiper\. {The Lord} (\kurios\). Some MSS. add \Isous\. The use of \kurios\ here is usually understood to mean the Lord Jesus Christ, as Clement of Alex. (_Adumbr_. p. 133) explains, strkjv@Exodus:23:20|, by \ho mustikos ekeinos aggelos Isous\ (that mystical angel Jesus). For the mystic reference to Christ see strkjv@1Corinthians:10:4,9; strkjv@Hebrews:11:26|. Some MSS. here add \theos\ instead of \Isous\. {Afterward} (\to deuteron\). Adverbial accusative, "the second time." After having saved the people out of Egypt. {Destroyed} (\aplesen\). First aorist active indicative of \apollumi\, old verb, to destroy. {Them that believed not} (\tous m pisteusantas\). First aorist active articular participle of \pisteu\. The reference is to strkjv@Numbers:14:27-37|, when all the people rescued from Egypt perished except Caleb and Joshua. This first example by Jude:is not in II Peter, but is discussed in strkjv@1Corinthians:10:5-11; strkjv@Hebrews:3:18-4:2|.

rwp@Jude:1:6 @{And angels} (\aggelous de\). The second example in Jude, the fallen angels, accusative case after \tetrken\ (perfect active indicative of \tre\, for which verb see strkjv@2Peter:2:4,7|) at the end of the verse (two emphatic positions, beginning and end of the clause). {Kept not} (\m trsantas\). First aorist active participle with negative \m\, with play on "kept not" and "he hath kept." {Principality} (\archn\). Literally, "beginning," "rule," (first place of power as in strkjv@1Corinthians:15:24; strkjv@Romans:8:38|). In strkjv@Acts:10:11| it is used for "corners" (beginnings) of the sheet. In strkjv@Ephesians:6:12| the word is used for evil angels. See strkjv@Deuteronomy:32:8|. Both Enoch and Philo (and Milton) discuss the fallen angels. {But left} (\alla apolipontas\). Second aorist active participle of \apoleip\, old verb, to leave behind (2Timothy:4:13,20|). {Their own proper habitation} (\to idion oiktrion\). Old word for dwelling-place (from \oiktr\, dweller at home, from \oikos\), in N.T. only here and strkjv@2Corinthians:5:2| (the body as the abode of the spirit). {In everlasting bonds} (\desmois aidiois\). Either locative (in) or instrumental (by, with). \Aidios\ (from \aei\, always), old adjective, in N.T. only here and strkjv@Romans:1:20| (of God's power and deity). It is synonymous with \ainios\ (Matthew:25:46|). Mayor terms \aidios\ an Aristotelian word, while \ainios\ is Platonic. {Under darkness} (\hupo zophon\). See strkjv@2Peter:2:4| for \zophos\. In Wisd. strkjv@17:2 we find \desmioi skotous\ (prisoners of darkness). {Great} (\megals\). Not in strkjv@2Peter:2:9|, which see for discussion.

rwp@Jude:1:7 @{Even as} (\hs\). Just "as." The third instance (Jude:passes by the deluge) in Jude, the cities of the plain. {The cities about them} (\hai peri autas poleis\). These were also included, Admah and Zeboiim (Deuteronomy:29:23; strkjv@Hosea:11:8|). Zoar, the other city, was spared. {In like manner} (\ton homoion tropon\). Adverbial accusative (cf. \hs\). Like the fallen angels. {Having given themselves over to fornication} (\ekporneusasai\). First aorist active participle feminine plural of \ekporneu\, late and rare compound (perfective use of \ek\, outside the moral law), only here in N.T., but in LXX (Genesis:38:24; strkjv@Exodus:34:15f.|, etc.). Cf. \aselgeian\ in verse 4|. {Strange flesh} (\sarkos heteras\). Horrible licentiousness, not simply with women not their wives or in other nations, but even unnatural uses (Romans:1:27|) for which the very word "sodomy" is used (Genesis:19:4-11|). The pronoun \heteras\ (other, strange) is not in strkjv@2Peter:2:10|. {Are set forth} (\prokeintai\). Present middle indicative of \prokeimai\, old verb, to lie before, as in strkjv@Hebrews:12:1f|. {As an example} (\deigma\). Predicate nominative of \deigma\, old word (from \deiknumi\ to show), here only in N.T., sample, specimen. strkjv@2Peter:2:6| has \hupodeigma\ (pattern). {Suffering} (\hupechousai\). Present active participle of \hupech\, old compound, to hold under, often with \dikn\ (right, justice, sentence strkjv@2Thessalonians:1:9|) to suffer sentence (punishment), here only in N.T. {Of eternal fire} (\puros ainiou\). Like \desmois aidiois\ in verse 7|. Cf. the hell of fire (Matthew:5:22|) and also strkjv@Matthew:25:46|. Jude:has no mention of Lot.

rwp@Jude:1:8 @{Yet} (\mentoi\). See strkjv@John:4:27|. In spite of these warnings. {In like manner} (\homois\). Like the cities of the plain. {These also} (\kai houtoi\). The false teachers of verse 4|. {In their dreamings} (\enupniazomenoi\). Present middle participle of \enupniaz\, to dream (from \enupnion\ dream, strkjv@Acts:2:17|, from \en\ and \hupnos\, in sleep), in Aristotle, Hippocrates, Plutarch, papyri, LXX (Joel:2:28|), here only in N.T. Cf. strkjv@Colossians:2:18|. {Defile} (\miainousin\). Present active indicative of \minain\, old verb, to stain, with sin (Titus:1:15|) as here. strkjv@2Peter:2:10| has \miasmou\. {Set at nought} (\athetousin\). Present active indicative of \athete\, to annul. Both \kuriots\ (dominion) and \doxai\ (dignities) occur in strkjv@2Peter:2:10|, which see for discussion.

rwp@Jude:1:9 @{Michael the archangel} (\ho Michael ho archaggelos\). Michael is mentioned also in strkjv@Daniel:10:13,21; strkjv@12:1; strkjv@Revelation:12:7|. \Archaggelos\ in N.T. occurs only here and strkjv@1Thessalonians:4:16|, but in strkjv@Daniel:10:13,20; strkjv@12:1|. {Contending with the devil} (\ti diaboli diakrinomenos\). Present middle participle of \diakrin\, to separate, to strive with as in strkjv@Acts:11:2|. Dative case \diaboli\. {When he disputed} (\hote dielegeto\). Imperfect middle of \dialegomai\ as in strkjv@Mark:9:34|. {Concerning the body of Moses} (\peri tou Muses smatos\). Some refer this to strkjv@Zechariah:3:1|, others to a rabbinical comment on strkjv@Deuteronomy:34:6|. There is a similar reference to traditions in strkjv@Acts:7:22; strkjv@Galatians:3:19; strkjv@Hebrews:2:2; strkjv@2Timothy:3:8|. But this explanation hardly meets the facts. {Durst not bring} (\ouk etolmsen epenegkein\). "Did not dare (first aorist active indicative of \tolma\), to bring against him" (second aorist active infinitive of \epipher\). {A railing accusation} (\krisin blasphmias\). "Charge of blasphemy" where strkjv@2Peter:2:11| has "\blasphmon krisin\." Peter also has \para kurii\ (with the Lord), not in Jude. {The Lord rebuke thee} (\epitimsai soi kurios\). First aorist active optative of \epitima\, a wish about the future. These words occur in strkjv@Zechariah:3:1-10| where the angel of the Lord replies to the charges of Satan. Clement of Alex. (_Adumb. in Ep. Judae_) says that Jude:quoted here the _Assumption of Moses_, one of the apocryphal books. Origen says the same thing. Mayor thinks that the author of the _Assumption of Moses_ took these words from Zechariah and put them in the mouth of the Archangel Michael. There is a Latin version of the _Assumption_. Some date it as early as B.C. 2, others after A.D. 44.

rwp@Jude:1:10 @{Whatsoever things they know not} (\hosa ouk oidasin\). Here strkjv@2Peter:2:12| has \en hois agnoousin\. The rest of the sentence is smoother than strkjv@2Peter:2:12|. {Naturally} (\phusiks\). Here only in N.T. strkjv@2Peter:2:12| has \gegennmena phusika\. Jude:has the article \ta\ with \aloga za\ and the present passive \phtheirontai\ instead of the future passive \phtharsontai\.

rwp@Jude:1:11 @{Woe to them} (\ouai autois\). Interjection with the dative as is common in the Gospels (Matthew:11:21|). {Went} (\eporeuthsan\). First aorist passive (deponent) indicative of \poreuomai\. {In the way of Cain} (\ti hodi tou Kain\). Locative case \hodi\. Cain is Jude's fourth example. Not in II Peter, but in strkjv@Hebrews:11:4; strkjv@1John:3:11f|. From strkjv@Genesis:4:7|. {Ran riotously} (\exechuthsan\). First aorist passive indicative of \ekche\, to pour out, "they were poured out," vigorous metaphor for excessive indulgence. But it is used also of God's love for us (Romans:5:5|). {In the error of Balaam} (\ti plani tou Balaam\). The fifth example in Jude. In II Peter also (2Peter:2:15|). Either locative case (in) or instrumental (by). \Plan\ (in Peter also) is the common word for such wandering (Matthew:24:4ff.|, etc.). {Perished} (\aplonto\). Second aorist middle (intransitive) of \apollumi\. {In the gainsaying of Korah} (\ti antilogii tou Kore\). Again either locative or instrumental. The word \antilogia\ is originally answering back (Hebrews:6:16|), but it may be by act also (Romans:10:21|) as here. This is the sixth example in Jude, not in II Peter.

rwp@Jude:1:12 @{Hidden rocks} (\spilades\). Old word for rocks in the sea (covered by the water), as in Homer, here only in N.T. strkjv@2Peter:2:13| has \spiloi\. {Love-feasts} (\agapais\). Undoubtedly the correct text here, though A C have \apatais\ as in strkjv@2Peter:2:14|. For disorder at the Lord's Supper (and love-feasts?) see strkjv@1Corinthians:11:17-34|. The Gnostics made it worse, so that the love-feasts were discontinued. {When they feast with you} (\suneuchoumenoi\). See strkjv@2Peter:2:13| for this very word and form. Masculine gender with \houtoi hoi\ rather than with the feminine \spilades\. Cf. strkjv@Revelation:11:4|. Construction according to sense. {Shepherds that feed themselves} (\heautous poimainontes\). "Shepherding themselves." Cf. strkjv@Revelation:7:17| for this use of \poimain\. Clouds without water (\nephelai anudroi\). \Nephel\ common word for cloud (Matthew:24:30|). strkjv@2Peter:2:17| has \pgai anudroi\ (springs without water) and then \homichlai\ (mists) and \elaunomenai\ (driven) rather than \peripheromenai\ here (borne around, whirled around, present passive participle of \peripher\ to bear around), a powerful picture of disappointed hopes. {Autumn trees} (\dendra phthinoprina\). Late adjective (Aristotle, Polybius, Strabo) from \phthin\, to waste away, and \opra\, autumn, here only in N.T. For \akarpa\ (without fruit) see strkjv@2Peter:1:8|. {Twice dead} (\dis apothanonta\). Second aorist active participle of \apothnsk\. Fruitless and having died. Having died and also "uprooted" (\ekrizthenta\). First aorist passive participle of \ekrizo\, late compound, to root out, to pluck up by the roots, as in strkjv@Matthew:13:29|.

rwp@Jude:1:13 @{Wild waves} (\kumata agria\). Waves (Matthew:8:24|, from \kue\, to swell) wild (from \agros\, field, wild honey strkjv@Matthew:3:4|) like untamed animals of the forest or the sea. {Foaming out} (\epaphrizonta\). Late and rare present active participle of \epaphriz\, used in Moschus for the foaming waves as here. Cf. strkjv@Isaiah:57:20|. {Shame} (\aischunas\). Plural "shames" (disgraces). Cf. strkjv@Phillipians:3:19|. {Wandering stars} (\asteres plantai\). "Stars wanderers." \Plants\, old word (from \plana\), here alone in N.T. Some refer this to comets or shooting stars. See strkjv@Isaiah:14:12| for an allusion to Babylon as the day-star who fell through pride. {For ever} (\eis aina\). The rest of the relative clause exactly as in strkjv@2Peter:2:17|.

rwp@Jude:1:14 @{And to these also} (\de kai toutois\). Dative case, for these false teachers as well as for his contemporaries. {Enoch the seventh from Adam} (\hebdomos apo Adam Hench\). The genealogical order occurs in strkjv@Genesis:5:4-20|, with Enoch as seventh. He is so termed in Enoch strkjv@60:8; strkjv@93:3. {Prophesied} (\eprophteusen\). First aorist active indicative of \prophteu\. If the word is given its ordinary meaning as in strkjv@1Peter:1:10|, then Jude:terms the Book of Enoch an inspired book. The words quoted are "a combination of passages from Enoch" (Bigg), chiefly from Enoch strkjv@1:9. {With ten thousand of his holy ones} (\en hagiais muriasin autou\). "With (\en\ of accompaniment, strkjv@Luke:14:31|) his holy ten thousands" (\murias\ regular word, feminine gender, for ten thousand, strkjv@Acts:19:19|, there an unlimited number like our myriads, strkjv@Luke:12:1|).

rwp@Jude:1:15 @{To execute judgment} (\poisai krisin\). "To do justice." {To convict} (\elegxai\). First aorist (effective) active infinitive like \poisai\ before it. {Ungodly} (\asebeis\). See verse 4| and end of this verse. {Of ungodliness} (\asebeias\). Old word as in strkjv@Romans:1:18|, plural in strkjv@Jude:1:18| as in strkjv@Romans:11:26|. {Which} (\hn\). Genitive by attraction from \ha\ (cognate accusative with \sebsan\, old verb, to act impiously, here alone in N.T. save some MSS. in strkjv@2Peter:2:6|) to agree with the antecedent \ergn\ (deeds). {Hard things} (\sklrn\). Harsh, rough things as in strkjv@John:6:60|. {Which} (\hn\). Genitive by attraction from \ha\ (object of \elalsan\, first aorist active indicative of \lale\) to the case of the antecedent \sklrn\. Four times in this verse as a sort of refrain \asebeis\ (twice), \asebeias, sebsan\.

rwp@Jude:1:16 @{Murmurers} (\goggustai\). Late onomatopoetic word for agent, from \gogguz\ (Matthew:20:11; strkjv@1Corinthians:10:10|) in the LXX (Exodus:16:8; strkjv@Numbers:11:1,14-29|). {Complainers} (\mempsimoiroi\). Rare word (Isocrates, Aristotle, Plutarch) from \memphomai\ to complain and \moira\ lot or fate. Here alone in N.T. {Lusts} (\epithumias\). As in strkjv@2Peter:3:3|. {Swelling} (\huperogka\). Songs:in strkjv@2Peter:2:18| (big words). {Showing respect of persons} (\thaumazontes prospa\). Present active participle of \thaumaz\ to admire, to wonder at. Nowhere else in N.T. with \prospa\, but a Hebraism (in strkjv@Leviticus:19:15; strkjv@Job:13:10|) like \lambanein prospon\ (Luke:20:21|) and \blepein prospon\ (Matthew:22:16|) and \prosoplempte\ (James:2:9|). Cf. strkjv@James:2:1|. {For the sake of advantage} (\pheleias charin\). To themselves. See also verse 11|. The covetousness of these Gnostic leaders is plainly shown in strkjv@2Peter:2:3,14|. For \charin\ as preposition with genitive see strkjv@Ephesians:3:1,14|.

rwp@Jude:1:17 @{Remember ye} (\humeis mnsthte\). First aorist passive (deponent) imperative of \mimnsk\ with genitive \rmatn\ (words). In strkjv@2Peter:3:2| we have the indirect form (infinitive \mnsthnai\). The rest as in II Peter, but in simpler and more exact structure and with the absence of \tn hagin prophtn\ (the holy prophets).

rwp@Jude:1:18 @{How that} (\hoti\). Declarative \hoti\ as in verse 5|. See discussion of strkjv@2Peter:3:3| for differences, no \en empaigmoni\ here and no \tn asebein\ there.

rwp@Jude:1:19 @{They who make separations} (\hoi apodiorizontes\). Present active articular participle of the double compound \apodioriz\ (from \apo, dia, horiz, horos\, boundary, to make a horizon), rare word, in Aristotle for making logical distinctions, here only in N.T. \Dioriz\ occurs in strkjv@Leviticus:20:24| and \aphoriz\ in strkjv@Matthew:25:32|, etc. See \haireseis\ in strkjv@2Peter:2:1|. {Sensual} (\psuchikoi\). Old adjective from \psuch\ as in strkjv@1Corinthians:2:14; strkjv@15:44; strkjv@James:3:15|. Opposed to \pneumatikos\. Not used by Peter. {Having not the Spirit} (\pneuma m echontes\). Usual negative \m\ with the participle (present active of \ech\). Probably \pneuma\ here means the Holy Spirit, as is plain in verse 20|. Cf. strkjv@Romans:8:9|.

rwp@Jude:1:20 @{Building up} (\epoikodomountes\). Present active participle of \epoikodome\, old compound with metaphor of a house (\oikos\), common in Paul (1Corinthians:3:9-17; strkjv@Colossians:2:7; strkjv@Ephesians:2:20|). {On your most holy faith} (\ti hagitati humn pistei\). For the spiritual temple see also strkjv@1Peter:2:3-5|. See \pistis\ (faith) in this sense (cf. strkjv@Hebrews:11:1|) in strkjv@2Peter:1:5| with the list of graces added. A true superlative here \hagitati\, not elative. {Praying in the Holy Spirit} (\en pneumati hagii proseuchomenoi\). This is the way to build themselves up on their faith.

rwp@Jude:1:21 @{Keep yourselves} (\heautous trsate\). First aorist active imperative (of urgency) of \tre\. In verse 1| they are said to be kept, but note the warning in verse 5| from the angels who did not keep their dominion. See also strkjv@James:1:27|. In strkjv@Phillipians:2:12| both sides (human responsibility and divine sovereignty are presented side by side). {Looking for} (\prosdechomenoi\). Present middle participle of \prosdechomai\, the very form in strkjv@Titus:2:13|. The same idea in \prosdokntes\ in strkjv@2Peter:3:14|.

rwp@Jude:1:22 @{And on some} (\kai hous men\). Demonstrative plural of \hos men--hos de\ (\hous de\, below), not the relative \hous\, but by contrast (\men, de\). Songs:Matthew:13:8|. {Have mercy} (\elete\). Present active imperative of \elea\ (rare form in strkjv@Romans:9:16| also for the usual \elee\ strkjv@Matthew:9:27|). But A C read \elegchete\, refute, in place of \eleate\. The text of this verse is in much confusion. {Who are in doubt} (\diakrinomenous\). Present middle participle of \diakrin\, in the accusative case agreeing with \hous men\, though K L P have the nominative. If the accusative and \eleate\ is read, see strkjv@James:1:6| for the idea (doubters). If \elegchete\ is read, see strkjv@Jude:1:9| for the idea (disputers).

rwp@Jude:1:23 @{And some save} (\hous de szete\). B omits \hous de\. {Snatching them out of the fire} (\ek puros harpazontes\). Present active participle of \harpaz\, old verb, to seize. Quotation from strkjv@Amos:4:11| and strkjv@Zechariah:3:3|. Cf. strkjv@Psalms:106:18|. Firemen today literally do this rescue work. Do Christians? {And on some have mercy with fear} (\hous de elete en phobi\). In fear "of the contagion of sin while we are rescuing them" (Vincent). For this idea see strkjv@1Peter:1:17; strkjv@3:15; strkjv@2Corinthians:7:1; strkjv@Phillipians:2:12|. {Spotted} (\espilmenon\). Perfect passive participle of \spilo\, late and common verb (from \spilos\, spot, strkjv@2Peter:2:13|), in N.T. only here and strkjv@James:3:6|.

rwp@Jude:1:24 @{From stumbling} (\aptaistous\). Verbal from \ptai\, to stumble (James:3:2; strkjv@2Peter:1:10|), sure-footed as of a horse that does not stumble (Xenophon), and so of a good man (Epictetus, Marcus Antoninus). {Before the presence of his glory} (\katenpion ts doxs autou\). Late compound preposition (\kata, en, ps\), right down before the eye of his glory as in strkjv@Ephesians:1:4|. Cf. strkjv@Matthew:25:31-33; strkjv@Colossians:1:22|, where Paul has \parastsai\ like \stsai\ here (first aorist active infinitive) and also \ammous\ as here, but \ammtos\ in strkjv@2Peter:3:14|. {In exceeding joy} (\en agalliasei\). See strkjv@Luke:1:14|.

rwp@Jude:1:25 @{To the only God our Saviour} (\moni thei stri hmn\). Dative in the noble doxology. See strkjv@Romans:16:27|, \moni sophi thei\ (to the alone wise God), where also we have \dia Isou Christou\, but without \tou kuriou hmn\ (our Lord) as here. \Str\ is used of God eight times in the N.T., six of them in the Pastoral Epistles. \Doxa\ (glory) to God or Christ in all the doxologies except strkjv@1Timothy:6:16|. \Megalosun\ (Majesty) is a late LXX word, in N.T. only here and strkjv@Hebrews:1:3; strkjv@8:1|. {Before all time} (\pro pantos tou ainos\). Eternity behind us. See same idea in strkjv@1Corinthians:2:7| \pro tn ainn\. {Now} (\nun\). The present. {For ever more} (\eis pantas tous ainas\). "Unto all the ages." All the future. As complete a statement of eternity as can be made in human language.